Roasted Red Pepper Pimento Cheese
As we approach the start of school, the cooking around here gets more and more indulgent. And, if you are a college-bound student, pretty much the sky’s the limit for what you can request and probably get!
College Girl is obsessed with several foods. Pickles. Steak. Cheese. Actually, pickles with cheese. Sometimes steak with cheese. And always, cheese with cheese. Which is the very definition of pimento cheese, by the way.
There are lots of good Southern recipes for pimento cheese, but basically you need some yellow cheese, some white cheese, some red tidbits and something to spice it up!
And this particular recipe is pretty addictive. College Girl powered through a bowl of it in 2 days. Impressive, considering we had only the baguette shown in the picture. Meaning I forgot to buy crackers. Oops.
The only slightly different thing I did was to roast my own red garden peppers and douse them in red wine vinegar instead of using jarred pimento. It was a nice touch, but really it is ALL about the cheese!
Gather Up:
4 ounces cream cheese, softened
1 cup cheddar cheese, grated
1 cup Monterey jack cheese, grated
2 tablespoons mayonnaise
2 teaspoons red wine vinegar
2 mild red chiles, roasted, skinned, seeded and diced (about ½ cup)
1 small onion, grated
2 cloves garlic, worked into a paste with kosher salt
½ teaspoon smoked paprika
Hot sauce, to taste
Freshly ground black pepper, to taste
Toasted baguette, crackers for serving
Mix the red wine vinegar and the diced red peppers together. Mix remaining ingredients together and add red pepper mixture. Taste and adjust seasoning. Cover and refrigerate before serving to blend flavors.









How absolutely delicious! That wouldn’t last long in my house either!
Impressed by what you call the small detail of pickling your garden grown peppers…and also impressed by yesterday’s homemade pastry… I still haven’t attempted that.
Oh MY!! First of all- LOVE your site! So adorable! And secondly- I looooove pimento cheese!! This looks fantastic!
Oh my gosh! We love cheese a little too much at our house. This would be a huge hit for sure!
I have some of those same little bowls. I just love using them!
Homegrown, roasted peppers sound fantastic! I’d love to work through a bowl of this with a baguette.
Hand over the bread and I could definitely eat this up. Thanks.
Plan B
It’s hard to find a good pimento cheese recipe and this sounds and looks fantastic! I’d have a hard time not devouring the whole thing at once!
I do so love pimento cheese- this sounds sooooo good. (And I prefer baguettes to crackers, thank you!)
College girl reminds me of myself, when I was in college! This recipe sounds like a great one for a get-together! Or perfect for snacking at home all by myself, who am I kidding? heh
Excellent! I’ve only ever had the processed pimiento cheese and would love to try a fresh, homemade version. Everything about it sounds marvelous!
I am absolutely crazy about pimento cheese! Thanks for the idea of making it with cream cheese. Bet that makes it extra creamy and cheesy:)
P.S. I’ve been reading the down home with the neely’s cookbook and they actually have a recipe for pimento cheese crostini that is served right on crusty bread just like yours:)
Yummie, this combination of different cheeses in a cream just look so tasty with roasted red peppers..great to serve as an appetizers…