The Ones that Replaced Break-n-Bake
The fall semester of my senior year of college is about to start! After a whole summer of traveling and restaurant food (I’m not complaining by the way), I’ve been seriously craving some homemade food. As I started to pack up my stuff to move back into my house on campus, I came across this chocolate chip cookie recipe. Here’s the thing: the Irish cuisine was fantastic, and the New York pizza was cheesy amazingness…but nothing hits the spot like a homemade chocolate chip cookie. And these are the very best.
A little history on these cookies: I spent many semesters making a “study snack” of break-n-bake cookies in the wee hours of the morning. They were fast, cheap, and easy. But once I discovered these cookies, I never went back. They are so good that I’m willing to take the extra 30 minutes to mix up the dough and wait for their chocolatey goodness to bake. While 30 minutes doesn’t sound like much, when its 2 am and there is an accounting final the next morning, I need all the time I can get to study! One thing is for sure, nothing does a better job of consoling this hungry, chocolate-craving college student at 2 am than these cookies. Plus, they don’t require an electric mixer!
Gather up:
1 stick unsalted butter
¾ cup packed brown sugar
¾ cup sugar
2 eggs
1 tsp. vanilla extract
12 oz. semisweet chocolate chips
2 ¼ cups all purpose flour
¾ tsp baking soda
1 tsp salt
Preheat your oven to 375 degrees. Melt butter in a microwave safe container. While the butter cools, combine flour, baking soda, and salt in a small bowl.
Combine butter with remaining ingredients in a large bowl. Be careful not to overmix the wet ingredients! They should be just combined.
Stir the chocolate chips into your wet ingredients.
Dump dry ingredients into wet ingredients and mix with a wooden spoon. Do not overmix! Again, ingredients should be just blended. We’ve found that overmixing leads to flat cookies, and when done right, these cookies are dense and fluffy. YUM.
Using a cookie scoop, spoon, or your hands, make 1.5-inch balls of dough, and drop them on the cookie sheet.
Cook for 10-12 minutes. After removing from oven, allow to cool for 1-2 minutes, and then move to a cooling rack.
And there you have it: the most amazing chocolate chip cookies ever, a.k.a the ones that replaced break-n-bake!
Recipe from Food Network.















Am I correct while reading this only has one stick of butter? 1/2 c right? Just wanted to make sure. Doesn’t seem like enough when most recipes call for 1 c (2 sticks). Look really good. I have to say, I am a huge fan of my own cookies but am always willing to give someone elses a shot. Love the thickness of yours. Mine turn out similar but with two sticks. That’s why I am asking is all.
Found this recipe on foodgawker and I was definitely enticed by the description. Then I read the post and knew that these would be an excellent addition to study time! I kept reading ya’lls blog (which is wonderful, by the way) and saw that college girl is a student in Austin. I’m currently going into my third year at UT and just thought it was so interesting that of all the blogs on Foodgawker to get sidetracked by, I’d find another Austin baker! Thanks for the recipe, I certainly intend on baking these these when school starts later this month.
Debbi
Those cookies look too good to be true. I must bake them, maybe even today.
Yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!! Your photo made it on foodgawker! I knew it would. Congratulations. I’m bookmarking this recipe, by the way.
P.S. Most of my stuff is out of my house. If the Lord wills, I should be leaving on Monday or Tuesday evening.
Wow – now that is my kind of cookie. Thick, dense, chocolatey and chewy.
This is one that I would definitely like to try.
Amaizing! I just baked a batch of these and everyone love it! thanks for sharing.
These cookies came out GREAT! Plus, since it required no electric mixer, I was able to let my 5 and 3 year old do most of the ‘cooking.’ Thanks for the recipe!
Caution! I ate all of these in two days. Super delicious and so easy.
I found your recipe on foodgawker and was attracted by your photos of delicious-looking cookies and extremely intrigued by the unusual mixing method. How much difference could it make, I wondered? I’ve tried a number of chocolate chip cookie recipes, and I like some better than others, but the differences are never significant enough to get excited about. Anyway I gathered up the ingredients, just liked you said, and whipped up a batch. And, not to be all hyperbolic about it or anything but…this is it – the holy grail of chocolate chip cookie recipes. These are the best ever. The. Best. Ever. Thank you so much for sharing.
I saw these and thought they looked wonderful, so I decided to try them. I’ve never made chocolate chip cookies from scratch and figured that they would not turn out very well. When the cookies were done they didn’t lay as flat as the pictures…that being said, these are DELICIOUS and very easy. I made mine to take to someone else…we’ll see if they make it there…
My roommate and I just made these… BEST COOKIES EVER.
These cookies are wonderful. I would only decrease the salt the next time. Otherwise, these are about as close to perfection as I’ve ever achieved.
These cookie are really amazing. They might be my favorite! I have made countless chocolate chip cookie recipes and these are great.. especially after the dough is refrigerated for 24 hours!
Found this page just stumbling (stumble upon) through the net. And I just HAVE to bake a batch right now!!!
Just in the oven!!! Misplaced the big baking trays in the move so had to use a small one and cook four at a time! Also my supermarket was out of chocolate chips so I shattered chocolate and used big lumps, hopefully they will taste just as good as yours!!
My cookies didnt turn out anything like this. They went all crispy, no matter how long I cooked them for. I really want to achieve a soft cookie. Any tips?
Seriously the best chocolate chip cookies ever! I made them last night with a girlfriend and it took no time!. We ate them hot and they were delicious!! Thanks for sharing the recipe!
I NEVER comment on recipes, but I couldn’t resist this time. I love this recipe! These cookies are so easy and delicious, and they look pretty too!
I used 1/2 dark chocolate chips and 1/2 peanut butter chips in order to get them out of my freezer. Very tasty! Thanks for sharing this!
Rebecca- so sorry they didn’t turn out! Unfortunately, unlike many cookie recipes, these directions are not very forgiving and one mixing stroke too many can cause flat, crispy cookies. It took us a few tries to get them right as well! I really hope you’ll give them another try and just remember to stop mixing after the ingredients are barely combined.
These look so amazing (and all the comments sound great too!)I’m from Australia and just tried making them and they turned into…well puddles & think this is due to the amount of butter i used. I was wondering, what is a “stick” of butter in grams (incase our sticks over here are more)?
Is the recipe for a dozen cookies?
Hi Michelle – we usually get about 30 cookies out of this recipe. Hope you like them!
Hi there! Just found your blog via StumbleUpon. I’ve made the same chocolate chip cookies for years and just decided to find a new recipe to try … after all, maybe there is a better recipe out there! I gave your recipe a shot and am delighted to say this is my new go-to chocolate chip cookie recipe. Just delicious. Chewy and full of chocolate chips. Thanks so much for posting this! I can’t wait to try more of your recipes. You have a fan!
I have been experimenting with different chocolate chip cookies for a few years now. I must say after weeding through all the family recipes and all the celebrity chef recipes, these are by far the best I have ever made, perfect the first time and I’m sure even an inexperienced baker can have success with these!
Thanks so much!!
I have to say, thank you so much for this recipe. These cookies are beautiful and delicious as previously reviewed. I am making them for a gift, but I’m not sure they will last that long
[...] I made some chocolate chip, pecan, banana cookies. I used this recipe and added one mashed up banana, cookies will turn out softer than picture below. Share [...]
Wow, I just made these cookies and they are unbelievably delicious!!!!!
The recipe went straight into my recipe box. Thank you for sharing it
Found this recipe on pinterest and the description sounded so good…I decided to make them tonight! These are “the best” chocolate chip cookies I have ever made. They ars super chocolately and the perfect soft,chewy consistency! Love them! Thanks for sharing the recipe! : )
Just made these. They were fantastic! Easy to make, I followed recipe exactly and baked for 12 mins. They were just the way i like them. The outside had a little crunch and the inside was soft. They were very nice and puffy. Yummy!!
I love these cookies. I’ve been making them off and on now for a while, and lately they have been coming out super dry and not at all like the pictures. At first I thought I was making a mistake in the recipe, but now I don’t know. What are they supposed to look like when they are finished mixing?
Hi Cole–you want the dough to be *just* mixed together. If you over-mix, they tend to flatten out and get dry. Make sure you’re not over-mixing the wet or dry ingredients (do it by hand), and then stir them together by hand until all the ingredients are just barely blended together. Hope that helps! It’s hard not to over-mix–we do it, too!
[...] Like Mother Like Daughters – The Ones That Replaces Break-n-Bake 2. The Traveler’s Lunchbox – The Holy Grail Of Cookies 3. Lick The Bowl Good [...]
Just made these, they are wonderful! The exact words out of my husband’s mouth: “These are THE best cookies you have ever made!” my 14 month old son: “Mmmmmmm!”
so simple, easy & fast. I will always make my chocolate chip cookies this way now. Thank you!!
WOW!!!!! These cookies were AMAZING!!!!! They were very easy and just too good to be true! It’s hard to find a good chocolate chip cookie recipe these days,but you’ve nailed it!! Wonderful!!
These are literally THE BEST chocolate chip cookies I have EVER made. As my roommate said, they looked like “stock photo cookies”, aka perfect. Even though I was working with an oven that likes to burn the bottoms and undercook the rest, these cookies turned out absolutely perfect!
So I’ve made these cookies four times, and they are everyone’s favorites! And for Christmas I am going to make a bunch, roll them into balls,and give them away at Christmas! Really THE best chocolate cookie recipe EVER!! THANK YOU!!
I’ve made these cookies twice and sent them to my fiance and both he and every Sailor he’s shared them with has LOVED them!!! He keeps getting requests for me to send more! Thanks for the awesome recipe, it’s by far the best chocolate chip cookie recipe I’ve ever used!!
Emily–that’s so sweet! Thank you for sharing! Glad he loves them
I love cookies, but these are the absolute best cookies ever!