Peanut Butter Jam Cookies
These cookies are for the young and the young at heart! They are perfect to make with a helper, and they are seriously addictive enough to make it hard to give them away… (I know of what I speak – I ate six while they were warm…)
But give them away you must! Because who doesn’t love to receive a homemade treat for Valentine’s Day? One crumbly jam-kissed bite and the recipient will fall hopelessly in love! (I mean with the cookie, silly goose…)
Gather Up:
1 ½ cups flour
1 ½ teaspoons baking powder
¼ teaspoon salt
1 stick unsalted butter, room temperature
½ cup sugar
½ cup packed brown sugar
1 cup creamy peanut butter
1 egg
3/4 cup raspberry jam, stirred to loosen
Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
Whisk together the flour, baking powder and salt.
Beat the butter and the sugars with a mixer on medium speed until pale and fluffy.
Beat in peanut butter and then egg.
On low speed, beat in flour mixture just until dough forms.
Roll dough into 1 ½ inch balls (about 2 tablespoons). Place on baking sheet and gently press into a small round, repairing any cracked dough with your fingers.
Make a gentle indentation in the cookie.
Bake for 11 minutes. Remove from oven and gently reshape the indentation.
Fill with a generous dollop of jam. Bake an additional 4 minutes until cookies are firm.
Remove to a wire rack to cool. Jam-filled cookies can be stored at room temperature for 2 days.
From: Martha Stewart Living, February 2011









Mmm, mmm, those look delicious. I have always loved PB and jam together. A perfect v-day giftie!
These look wonderful. Nothing better than anything featuring pb & j!
Nancy, love the touch of raspberry jam on the cookies…they sure look very tempting…what a perfect match
All of your posts make me SOOOOOO hungry!!!!
I made cookies like this recently. But yours turned out way better than mine did, I posted pictures I found from the internet, mine weren’t worth taking pictures of! But they were still SO delicious!
How cute!
So cute! Let the inner child at em.
These are just so pretty! PB & Jelly is ultimate comfort food… What a perfect Vday gift
I love peanut butter cookies! Yours look so yummy, and the touch of raspberry jam sounds extra good!
What I love here is that you doubled up on the peanut butter and halved the amount of sugar normally used!
I remember these cookies being the first ones to go when I would be baking at home.
only six? I would have devoured at least a dozen, yummy..perfect for my girls to give as gifts….take care (silly goose)have a great week
sweetlife
Aww, these are so sweet! I’m always inclined to pair chocolate with PB, but of course jam is another perfect combo!
Oh, you bet! Homebaked love is a must for Valentine’s Day. These cookies are perfect! Yum!
I totally trust you on this one!
Those look so incredibly delicious!
Thee are two of my favorite cookies in one! You’re right who could resist
you had me at peanut butter! serious, this looks so good. thank you for sharing this.
Jam cookies are one of my favorites! These look just beautiful, and so soft and delicious! Thanks for sharing.
I’m all about the combo of PB & J! These cookies sounds super delicious and definitely worthy of being a Valentine’s treat!
What a wonderful way to showcase this classic combination of flavors. And beautiful too!
peanut butter cookies and jam are such a perfect combo. your cookies look so good. thanks for sharing
These are wonderful — a match made in Heaven, right? I love peanut butter cookies, but have never made them with jelly. SO perfect.
This look really scrumptious! I love the peanut butter and jelly combo! Yum!!
Classic PB and J combination, who could resist that? I love the bright jam colours on these!
I love these cookies! Aren’t they perfect for any holiday? And I commend you for refraining at six. I’m sure I would have eaten at least a dozen!
Peanut butter and jam…so good. These are going on my food to-do list LOL.
I would love to enjoy these for Valentine’s Day or any day. I enjoy this type of cookie. i could have joined you and eaten six warm cookies too.
Cheers to you!
Velva
I’d rather have these than a PB and jelly sandwich any day! Such scrumptious treats!
I’m all for anything with peanut butter lately! And, with a good berry jam, the match can’t be beat. These look irresistible!
I’ve made jam thumbprints a couple of times now but never with peanut butter. Yum! Definitely irresistible!
Happy Valentine’s Day. xo
I love peanut butter cookies and the jam makes them look so pretty…delicious!
I love peanut butter cookies and the jam makes them look so pretty…delicious!